Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Abraxas's avatar

Hear hear, I still think back to my time in infantry training and remember some of the truly impressive idiots we had (one guy literally did not know what the infantry did). They had some uses, but not many, and they weren't even terribly good as disposables. It's why most western militaries have moved away from conscripts to volunteers. It turns out war isn't just hard, it's complicated, and winning is difficult.

Expand full comment
wilson's avatar

A great article. The only 2 cents I can add is that as a former infantry and SF guy the range of things we had to know and be able to think through and act was damn near infinite. I always had contempt for the idiots who characterized us as cannon fodder. Those types wouldn't have lasted a day. And yeah, there were always dumb f...ks but that wasn't the norm. And that was before the "modern battlefield." Your comment about gamers is interesting. You do have to be able to do more than sit at a console for eight hours a day, like one young gamer told me he did. Of course, it's not as if I know anything about it because I don't.

Expand full comment
123 more comments...

No posts