Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Samstoevsky's avatar

It doesn’t seem clear to me that the revival of European paganism as a religion and the continuation of the great thinkers and poets of the Western tradition are the same thing. Of the pagan texts, I have only read the Iliad, Odyssey, Beowulf, The Saga of the Volsungs, and the Poetic Edda so this may be due to the fact that I’m not quite sure what the modern day paganism you are describing actually is. I think this is mainly a theological question.

Do you believe in the creation account described in Voluspa? Did Odin and his brothers create Midgard? Or was the creation something closer to Hesiod’s Theogony? This may be due to my monotheistic theory of mind, but I just don’t understand the theology and metaphysics of the pagan worldview. What is the theory of mind on the existence of the Greek/Roman/Norse gods, and do they exist in a different form today or are there possibly new gods?

Yes the texts have been preserved well, but what exactly is the relationship of the modern day reader to the text? Is it an authoritative source on metaphysics, morals, and history in the same way a Christians conscience is bound to submit to Scripture in order to call himself a Christian or is the mechanism different? I apologize for all the questions I’m just curious what claiming continuity with these traditions actually means.

Philomedia's avatar

An eerie piece, and most welcome. As I read along, my frustrated retired outsider teacher mind kept jumping ahead, apparently trying to beat you to the punch. “Crap argument! ALL the texts were copied and altered. Just look at the rows of bibles at a Barnes and Nobles (oh, wait…).” It felt absolutely weird.

To assert the role and role, value and significance of verse creates a myth-busting position in the face of and narrow and illogical, and poverty-stricken Western Christian mindset is important. Thank you.

My old educator’s heart felt a wave of relief while reading your poem, as I involuntarily, spontaneously, overlaid it with:

“I eat my peas with honey;

I’ve done it all my life.

It makes the peas taste funny,

But it keeps them on my knife.”

Rock and roll. The opinion that it is necessary and valuable to teach and learn through verse and memorization is in itself a heretical position in American public schools, at least. Folks are so conditioned to that position that they fundamentally numb out at the mere suggestion of it. However, it always has ever been, and remains, The Way.

If anyone doubts that, try teaching children The Tale of Custard the Dragon (Ogden Nash, 1936) by rote, set to Method Man and Red Man’s Da Rockwilder. Or quit having them read the soliloquies silently and have them start doing them, dramatically, aloud, in pairs, as if in dialogue.

As for the “pagan” material and content itself, it has always amazed me that even Classical educators can hold such a split mindset, nullifying thereby so much knowledge and richness. Senseless except as a strategy to maintain control of some version of some narrative.

I could go on and on in response. Not only did I find some joy, high entertainment and agreement here, but also inspiration to re-enter the fray with my pagan roots showing.

42 more comments...

Ready for more?